Choosing a marine chartplotter that relies on physical buttons rather than touchscreens alone can be a smart move for anglers who operate in wet conditions or wear gloves. While modern touchscreens offer sleek interfaces, physical controls provide tactile feedback that remains reliable when hands are slippery or when you are wearing thick fishing gloves. My analysis of the current market highlights that the Garmin ECHOMAP UHD2 53CV stands out as the best overall choice for most boaters due to its balance of size, sonar clarity, and intuitive button layout. For those needing a larger display without losing the benefits of physical keys, the Simrad NSS Evo3S offers a hybrid approach that appeals to serious offshore anglers. The primary tradeoff you will face is between the simplicity of compact, dedicated button units and the versatility of larger, multi-function displays that include touch as a secondary input method.
Get sports gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Physical buttons offer superior reliability in wet or gloved conditions compared to pure touchscreen units.
- The Garmin ECHOMAP UHD2 53CV provides the best balance of affordability and sonar performance for small to mid-sized boats.
- Simrad‘s NSS Evo3S series is ideal for users who want a large screen but still prefer rotary dials and keypads for primary control.
- Smaller 5-inch units like the Garmin UHD2 54CV are excellent for compact consoles but lack the screen real estate for detailed split-screen views.
- High-end units like the Garmin ECHOMAP Ultra 126sv prioritize screen size and mapping detail over dedicated physical button interfaces.
| Garmin ECHOMAP UHD2 53CV Chartplotter/Fishfinder |  | Best Overall for Small to Mid-Sized Boats | Display Size: 5 inches | Sonar Support: Traditional CHIRP and ClearVü | Preloaded Maps: US Inland Maps, LakeVü g3 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Simrad NSS Evo3S Multifunction Fish Finder Chartplotter |  | Best Premium Hybrid Control | Display Size: 9 inches | Display Type: LCD (SolarMAX IPS) | Maximum Measuring Depth: 3000 feet | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Garmin ECHOMAP UHD2 54CV Chartplotter/Fishfinder |  | Best Compact Value Option | Display: 5-inch keyed display | Sonar: CHIRP traditional and ClearVü | Connectivity: Wi-Fi | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Simrad GO Chartplotter and Fish Finder |  | Best for Touchscreen Integration | Transducer Frequency: 83/200 kHz HDI | Chart Card Included: C-MAP Discover | GPS Receiver: Built-in 10 Hz GPS | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Garmin ECHOMAP Ultra 126sv Chartplotter |  | Best Premium Large Screen | Display Size: 12 inches | Mapping: Preloaded Garmin Navionics+ | Sonar Support: UHD, CHIRP traditional, SideVü | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| button controlled marine chartplotter | Display Size | Connectivity |
|---|---|---|
| Garmin ECHOMAP UHD2 53CV Chart | 5 inches | Wi-Fi |
| Simrad NSS Evo3S Multifunction | 9 inches | — |
| Garmin ECHOMAP UHD2 54CV Chart | — | Wi-Fi |
| Simrad GO Chartplotter and Fis | — | — |
| Garmin ECHOMAP Ultra 126sv Cha | 12 inches | Wi-Fi, NMEA 2000 |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Garmin ECHOMAP UHD2 53CV Chartplotter/Fishfinder
This unit stands out for its straightforward interface that combines a 5-inch screen with a dedicated keypad. Unlike the larger Garmin Ultra series, which leans heavily on touch, the Garmin ECHOMAP UHD2 53CV ensures that critical functions are accessible via physical buttons. This makes it ideal for anglers who frequently handle wet lures or operate in rougher waters where screen touches might be accidental. Compared to the Simrad GO9, which is primarily a touchscreen device, the Garmin offers a more traditional, rugged feel that many users prefer for daily fishing tasks. The inclusion of CHIRP and ClearVü sonar means you do not sacrifice image quality for the sake of button controls. However, the 5-inch display can feel cramped when trying to view complex maps and sonar simultaneously, a limitation that becomes apparent when comparing it to the 9-inch Simrad NSS Evo3S.
Pros:- Intuitive button layout for easy operation with gloves.
- High-contrast sonar imaging aids in quick target identification.
- Preloaded maps reduce initial setup time significantly.
Cons:- Small 5-inch screen limits detailed map visibility.
- Advanced features often require smartphone app integration.
- Limited expandability compared to larger multi-function displays.
Best for: Anglers with small to mid-sized boats who prefer tactile controls for wet-hand operation.
Not ideal for: Users who need large map views for long-distance navigation or complex split-screen setups.
- Display Size:5 inches
- Sonar Support:Traditional CHIRP and ClearVü
- Preloaded Maps:US Inland Maps, LakeVü g3
- Connectivity:Wi-Fi
- Transducer Support:GT20-TM transducer included
- Mounting Options:Tilt and flush mount
Our verdict“A reliable, user-friendly choice for boaters who value tactile feedback over screen size.”
Simrad NSS Evo3S Multifunction Fish Finder Chartplotter
The Simrad NSS Evo3S is designed for those who want a large, bright display but still desire the precision of physical controls. It features a hybrid interface that allows users to switch between a touchscreen and a keypad with a rotary dial. This flexibility is a significant advantage over the Garmin ECHOMAP UHD2 53CV, which lacks the screen real estate for detailed offshore navigation. The SolarMAX IPS display remains clear even under direct sunlight, a feature that is essential for open-water boaters. While the Garmin models are more compact, the Simrad offers a 9-inch view that makes tracking waypoints and sonar returns much easier. However, this power comes with bulk; the unit is heavier and requires more substantial mounting hardware than the smaller Garmin options. It is overkill for small jon boats but perfect for offshore vessels needing robust, glove-friendly control.
Pros:- Bright IPS display is readable in direct sunlight.
- Hybrid control allows use of keypad or touchscreen.
- Powerful processor handles complex data smoothly.
Cons:- Heavy unit requires sturdy mounting solutions.
- Installation complexity is higher than plug-and-play models.
- Higher price point reflects premium features.
Best for: Offshore anglers and larger boat owners needing bright displays and hybrid control options.
Not ideal for: Small boat owners with limited console space or budget constraints.
- Display Size:9 inches
- Display Type:LCD (SolarMAX IPS)
- Maximum Measuring Depth:3000 feet
- Mounting Type:Flush Mount, Panel Mount
- Preloaded Charts:C-MAP US Enhanced
- Sonar Power:1 kW CHIRP
Our verdict“The top choice for serious boaters who need a large screen without sacrificing tactile control.”
Garmin ECHOMAP UHD2 54CV Chartplotter/Fishfinder
This model is essentially a streamlined version of the 53CV, focusing on core fishing features without some of the advanced navigation extras. The Garmin ECHOMAP UHD2 54CV maintains the same 5-inch keyed display, ensuring that the tactile benefits are preserved. It is a strong contender for those who want the Garmin ecosystem but have a tighter budget or simpler needs. Compared to the Simrad GO9, which offers a more modern touchscreen interface, the 54CV feels more utilitarian. It lacks the built-in GPS and chartplotting depth of the 53CV, making it better suited for anglers who primarily use the device for fish finding rather than complex navigation. If you already have a separate GPS or primarily fish in familiar waters, this unit delivers excellent sonar clarity at a lower cost. However, the lack of detailed preloaded maps means you must rely on external devices for navigation.
Pros:- Bright, easy-to-read 5-inch display.
- Dual sonar views enhance underwater imaging.
- Wi-Fi connectivity for basic data sharing.
Cons:- No built-in GPS or advanced chartplotting.
- Limited to 5-inch screen size.
- Requires compatible devices for full functionality.
Best for: Budget-conscious anglers who prioritize fish finding over detailed navigation.
Not ideal for: Navigators who need comprehensive charting capabilities in a single unit.
- Display:5-inch keyed display
- Sonar:CHIRP traditional and ClearVü
- Connectivity:Wi-Fi
- Mapping:LakeVü g3 and BlueChart maps
Our verdict“A solid, no-frills fish finder for boaters who don’t need advanced navigation features.”
Simrad GO Chartplotter and Fish Finder
While this unit is primarily a touchscreen device, it is included here for those who want a modern interface but still appreciate the option of physical remote controls. The Simrad GO9 XSE offers a sleek design that contrasts sharply with the button-heavy Garmin ECHOMAP UHD2 series. It is ideal for users who prefer a clean console look and use smartphone mirroring for control. However, the lack of dedicated physical buttons on the unit itself is a drawback for wet-hand operation, requiring users to rely on a separate remote or touch inputs. Compared to the Simrad NSS Evo3S, the GO9 is lighter and easier to install, making it a better fit for smaller boats. Yet, it lacks the rugged, tactile feel of the NSS series. This model is best for tech-savvy boaters who are comfortable with touch interfaces and want a multi-function display that integrates radar and sonar in a single, compact package.
Pros:- All-in-one navigation, sonar, and radar solution.
- Intuitive touchscreen interface with customizable views.
- Lightweight and easy to install on smaller boats.
Cons:- No dedicated physical buttons on the main unit.
- Automatic routing features are limited in the USA.
- May be overkill for basic navigation needs.
Best for: Tech-oriented boaters who prefer a clean console and use remote controls.
Not ideal for: Users who operate in wet conditions and need direct physical button access.
- Transducer Frequency:83/200 kHz HDI
- Chart Card Included:C-MAP Discover
- GPS Receiver:Built-in 10 Hz GPS
- Display Type:Multi-touch touchscreen
- Radar Compatibility:Simrad Broadband 3G, 4G
Our verdict“A modern, versatile option for those who don’t mind relying on touch or remote controls.”
Garmin ECHOMAP Ultra 126sv Chartplotter
The Garmin ECHOMAP Ultra 126sv is a powerhouse that prioritizes screen size and mapping detail over physical button interfaces. It features a massive 12-inch touchscreen that offers unparalleled visibility for complex navigation tasks. While it lacks the dedicated keypad of the smaller UHD2 models, it is designed for users who rely on app integration and touch controls. Compared to the Simrad NSS Evo3S, the Ultra 126sv offers a larger display but fewer tactile control options. It is ideal for large offshore vessels where the console is dry and protected, and where the user prefers the flexibility of a large, interactive map. The downside is the complexity; this unit is not beginner-friendly and requires a significant learning curve to master its advanced features. For those who strictly need button controls, this is likely the wrong choice, but for those seeking the ultimate visual experience, it is unmatched.
Pros:- High-resolution 12-inch sunlight-readable touchscreen.
- Preloaded detailed Navionics+ maps with auto guidance.
- Supports UHD sonar and LiveScope compatibility.
Cons:- Complex for first-time marine electronics users.
- Lacks dedicated physical button controls.
- Requires compatible transducers for full features.
Best for: Large boat owners who need maximum screen real estate and advanced mapping.
Not ideal for: Beginners or users who need glove-friendly physical buttons.
- Display Size:12 inches
- Mapping:Preloaded Garmin Navionics+
- Sonar Support:UHD, CHIRP traditional, SideVü
- Transducer:GT56UHD-TM bundled
- Connectivity:Wi-Fi, NMEA 2000
- Compatibility:Supports LiveScope
Our verdict“The ultimate choice for large vessels where screen size outweighs the need for physical buttons.”
How We Picked
I selected these five chartplotters based on their suitability for users who prioritize physical input methods over exclusive touchscreen reliance. I evaluated each unit’s control interface, specifically looking for dedicated keys, rotary dials, or hybrid systems that allow full operation without touching the screen. I also weighed the sonar performance, mapping accuracy, and build quality relative to the intended use case, whether that was coastal navigation, offshore fishing, or small lake cruising. My ranking favors units that maintain usability in harsh marine environments, ensuring that a wet hand or a cold day does not hinder your ability to mark a waypoint or adjust sonar settings.
| button controlled marine chartplotter | Connectivity |
|---|---|
| Garmin ECHOMAP UHD2 53CV Chart | Wi-Fi |
| Simrad NSS Evo3S Multifunction | — |
| Garmin ECHOMAP UHD2 54CV Chart | Wi-Fi |
| Simrad GO Chartplotter and Fis | — |
| Garmin ECHOMAP Ultra 126sv Cha | Wi-Fi, NMEA 2000 |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Button Controlled Marine Chartplotter
Selecting the right chartplotter involves more than just looking at screen size; it requires considering how you interact with the device while on the water. Here is what I recommend focusing on when making your decision.
Control Interface: Buttons vs. Touch
Physical buttons provide tactile feedback that is critical in wet conditions. If you often have wet hands or wear gloves, a unit with dedicated keys or a rotary dial, like the Simrad NSS Evo3S, is safer and more efficient. Touchscreens offer a cleaner look and more complex interface options but can be frustrating to use when your fingers are slippery. Hybrid units offer the best of both worlds, allowing you to switch between modes as conditions change.
Display Size and Readability
A 5-inch display is sufficient for small boats and basic navigation, as seen in the Garmin ECHOMAP UHD2 53CV. However, larger screens like the 9-inch Simrad or 12-inch Garmin Ultra provide better visibility for split-screen views, allowing you to see maps and sonar simultaneously. Consider your console space and typical viewing distance when choosing screen size. Larger screens also tend to have higher resolution, which improves map detail and sonar clarity.
Sonar and Mapping Capabilities
Not all chartplotters come with the best sonar technology. Look for CHIRP sonar for better target separation and ClearVü or SideVü for detailed structure imaging. Mapping quality is equally important; preloaded charts like C-MAP or Navionics+ save you money and time. Ensure the unit supports the transducer you need, whether it’s a basic GT20 or a high-end GT56, as this impacts the depth and clarity of your underwater views.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why choose a button-controlled chartplotter over a touchscreen?
Button-controlled chartplotters offer superior reliability in wet environments. When your hands are wet from rain, spray, or fish, touching a screen can be inaccurate or impossible. Physical buttons provide clear tactile feedback, allowing you to adjust settings or mark waypoints without looking at the device. This is especially important when wearing gloves in cold weather, where capacitive touchscreens often fail to register input.
Is a 5-inch display too small for serious fishing?
For many anglers, a 5-inch display is perfectly adequate for identifying fish and navigating local waters. Units like the Garmin ECHOMAP UHD2 53CV offer high-resolution screens that make details clear. However, if you need to view complex maps and sonar side-by-side, a 5-inch screen can feel cramped. Larger displays offer more flexibility for split-screen configurations, which can be beneficial for long-distance navigation.
Can I upgrade from a small chartplotter to a larger one later?
Upgrading is possible, but it often requires new wiring and mounting hardware. Most marine electronics are not plug-and-play across different sizes. If you anticipate needing a larger screen in the future, it may be more cost-effective to start with a mid-sized unit like the Simrad GO9 rather than a 5-inch model. Consider your long-term boating plans to avoid the hassle and expense of a complete console overhaul.
Do I need Wi-Fi on my chartplotter?
Wi-Fi connectivity allows for over-the-air updates and data sharing. It enables you to download new maps, share waypoints with other boaters, and use mobile apps for remote control. While not strictly necessary for basic navigation, Wi-Fi adds significant convenience and keeps your device current. Units like the Garmin ECHOMAP UHD2 use Wi-Fi to integrate with smartphone apps for enhanced functionality.
Are hybrid control chartplotters difficult to use?
Hybrid chartplotters, such as the Simrad NSS Evo3S, are designed to be intuitive. They allow you to switch between touch and physical controls seamlessly. The learning curve is minimal for users familiar with either interface. The main advantage is flexibility; you can use the touchscreen for zooming and panning maps and the keypad for precise adjustments, making it a versatile choice for varied conditions.
Conclusion
Choosing the right button-controlled chartplotter depends on your boat size and operational needs. For most small to mid-sized boaters, the Garmin ECHOMAP UHD2 53CV offers the best balance of price, performance, and tactile control. If you require a larger display for offshore navigation but still want physical keys, the Simrad NSS Evo3S is the superior premium choice. For budget-conscious anglers who prioritize fish finding over navigation, the Garmin ECHOMAP UHD2 54CV delivers excellent value. Ultimately, prioritize a control interface that works for you in the conditions you fish in most often.
